Comparing a Report and a News Story

Year 6 reading worksheet: compare a platypus information report with a local news story, use a glossary and subheadings and judge each text's purpose.

Year 6 English · 4 pages · 5 questions · Answer key

When this preview is focused, use the left and right arrow keys to move between pages.

Page 1 of 4

About this worksheet

A Year 6 English reading sheet built on two texts about the same animal. Text A is an information report on the platypus with the subheadings Appearance, Habitat, Food and Breeding and a glossary. Text B is a local news story, "Platypus back in Bellbird Creek", with a lead paragraph and a volunteer's quote.

Students define monotreme and electroreception, find three facts using the subheadings, compare the two texts in a table and decide which suits a school project. It links to Australian Curriculum v9 codes AC9E6LY03, AC9E6LY04 and AC9E6LY05. Page 4 has a completed table and model answers.

What's inside this worksheet

Page 1

Text A, The Platypus

An information report covering the venomous spur, habitat across eastern Australia, electroreception and egg laying, with a glossary of burrow, electroreception and monotreme.

Page 2

Text B, Local News Story

A short news story about a Landcare group spotting a platypus, written with emotive words such as thrilled and heartwarming.

Pages 2-3

Glossary Questions and Find Facts

Students define two glossary terms, then answer three questions by looking under Appearance, Habitat, Food and Breeding.

Page 3

Compare the Texts

A table asks for the purpose, structure, type of language and likely reader of each text.

Evaluate the Texts

Four lines to explain which text suits a school project on platypuses, with reference to its features.

Page 4

Answers

Gives both definitions, the three facts, a completed comparison table and a model answer for the final question.

Questions in this worksheet

Every question from the sheet, so you can check it fits your class before you print.

Text A: Information Report

  • The Platypus
  • Appearance
  • The platypus (Ornithorhynchus anatinus) is a semi-aquatic mammal native to Australia. It has a broad, leathery bill, dense waterproof fur, webbed feet and a flat, paddle-shaped tail. Adult males have a sharp, venomous spur on the inside of each back leg, which is used for defence during the breeding season.
  • Habitat
  • Platypuses live in freshwater creeks, slow-moving rivers and lakes across eastern Australia, including Tasmania. When resting out of the water, they shelter inside a long, narrow burrow dug into a muddy riverbank.
  • Food
  • The platypus is a carnivore that feeds at night on insect larvae, freshwater shrimp, yabbies and worms. Underwater, it closes its eyes, ears and nostrils, hunting entirely through electroreception by detecting tiny electrical signals from the muscles of its prey using sensitive receptors in its bill.
  • Breeding
  • The platypus is a monotreme, which is a rare type of mammal that lays eggs instead of giving birth to live young. There are only five living monotreme species in the world: the platypus and four species of echidna. Each spring, a female platypus lays between one and three leathery eggs inside a nesting burrow.
  • Glossary
  • burrow: a tunnel or hole dug in the ground by an animal for shelter or nesting.
  • electroreception: the ability to detect tiny natural electrical signals given off by living things.
  • monotreme: an egg-laying mammal; the five living species are the platypus and four echidnas.

Text B: Local News Story

  • Platypus back in Bellbird Creek
  • Thrilled local residents are celebrating a remarkable wildlife comeback after an elusive platypus was spotted swimming in Bellbird Creek on Saturday morning for the first time in over a decade.
  • A team from the Bellbird Creek Landcare Group made the heartwarming discovery at dawn while checking native reeds along the restored riverbank. For years, pollution and rubbish had driven the shy creatures away, making Saturday's sighting a joyful reward for the community.
  • Volunteer coordinator Maya Lin, who photographed ripples near the old footbridge, said the group was overjoyed by the wonderful news. 'We held our breath as it surfaced right in front of us,' Ms Lin said. 'Seeing a healthy platypus back in our neighbourhood creek proves that three years of hard work planting trees and clearing litter has truly paid off.'

Part 1: Glossary Questions

  • Use the glossary below Text A to write the definition of each term in your own words or directly from the glossary.

Part 2: Find Facts

  • Use the subheadings in Text A to locate the answers to these questions quickly.
  • 1. Look under Appearance. Where is the venomous spur located, and which platypuses have one?
  • 2. Look under Habitat and Food. Where does the platypus live, and how does it find prey when its eyes are closed underwater?
  • 3. Look under Breeding. How many living monotreme species exist, and how many eggs does a female platypus lay?

Part 3: Compare the Texts

  • 1. Complete the table below to compare Text A (the information report) and Text B (the local news story).
  • Feature
  • Text A: 'The Platypus'
  • Text B: 'Platypus back in Bellbird Creek'
  • Purpose (Why was it written?)
  • Structure (How is the text organised?)
  • Type of language (What kind of words are used?)
  • Who might read it? (Target audience)

Part 4: Evaluate the Texts

  • 1. Which text suits a school project on platypuses, and why? Refer to the features of the text in your explanation.

How teachers use it

Highlight first

Give students two colours. They mark technical words in Text A and emotive words in Text B before they start the comparison table.

Subheading race

Time the Find Facts questions. Students who use the subheadings finish fast, and the rest see why report writers use them.

Writing follow-up

Ask students to rewrite the first two sentences of Text B in the style of an information report. The change in language becomes very clear.

Curriculum objectives covered

AC9E6LY03

analyse how text structures and language features work together to meet the purpose of a text, and engage and influence audiences

Compare the Texts asks how the structure and language of a report and a news story suit their purposes and readers.

AC9E6LY04

select, navigate and read texts for a range of purposes, monitoring meaning and evaluating the use of structural features; for example, table of contents, glossary, chapters, headings and subheadings

Glossary Questions and Find Facts send students to the glossary and the subheadings in Text A.

AC9E6LY05

use comprehension strategies such as visualising, predicting, connecting, summarising, monitoring and questioning to build literal and inferred meaning, and to connect and compare content from a variety of sources

Evaluate the Texts asks students to compare content from both texts and choose one for a school project.

Want to change this worksheet?

Remix it in Chalkie to change the questions or make an easier version.

Remix for free